ElectoralMap.org
Babysitting your AI coding agent? Approve AI agent requests from the notch.Allow or deny without switching windowsA ping when the task finishes
Electoral College Guide · Constitutional Law

What is a faithless elector? Laws and Supreme Court rulings

Can presidential electors vote for whoever they want, or can states force them to follow the popular vote? Here is the legal breakdown.

The Elector's Constitutional Role

When Americans cast ballots for president, they are technically voting for a slate of electors selected by the candidate's political party. While electors take a pledge to vote for their party's nominee, historically some have broken that promise.

The Landmark 2020 Supreme Court Ruling: Chiafalo v. Washington

For decades, legal scholars debated whether electors were free agents under the Constitution or bound delegates. The issue reached the Supreme Court following the 2016 election, where several electors sought to prevent Donald Trump's election by casting rogue ballots.

In July 2020, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously (9–0) in Chiafalo v. Washington that:

“A State may penalize an elector for breaking his pledge and condition his appointment on voting for the winner of the State's popular vote.”

Writing for the court, Justice Elena Kagan noted that the Constitution grants states broad authority over appointing electors, which includes the power to condition that appointment on faithful voting.

How States Handle Rogue Electors Today

State laws across the country generally fall into three categories:

  • Strict Binding Laws (Over 30 states): If an elector attempts to cast a faithless vote, the ballot is immediately canceled, the elector is removed and replaced with an alternate elector.
  • Pledge with Fines (Several states): Electors pledge to vote for their candidate, and violations may trigger a misdemeanor fine (e.g., Washington state's $1,000 fine before it updated to an immediate replacement law).
  • No Formal Binding Law (Remaining states): Electors are bound only by party loyalty and personal honor.

The 2016 Record: 7 Faithless Ballots

The 2016 election witnessed the highest number of faithless electors in a single presidential election in over a century:

  • 3 Washington Electors voted for Colin Powell.
  • 1 Washington Elector voted for Native American activist Faith Spotted Eagle.
  • 1 Hawaii Elector voted for Bernie Sanders.
  • 1 Texas Elector voted for Ron Paul.
  • 1 Texas Elector voted for John Kasich.

Because Donald Trump held 306 pledged electors (well above the 270 needed), the 7 faithless votes did not impact the final outcome, leaving Trump with 304 EV and Hillary Clinton with 227 EV.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common Questions About Faithless Electors

What is a faithless elector?

A faithless elector is a member of the United States Electoral College who does not vote for the presidential or vice presidential candidate for whom they previously pledged to vote.

Did the Supreme Court rule on faithless electors?

Yes. In the unanimous 2020 landmark ruling Chiafalo v. Washington (and its companion case Colorado Department of State v. Baca), the U.S. Supreme Court held that states have the constitutional authority to penalize electors or replace them if they violate their pledge.

How many faithless electors have there been in U.S. history?

In total, there have been roughly 165 instances of faithlessness across U.S. history, but the vast majority occurred when a candidate died before electors met (such as Horace Greeley in 1872). In modern contested races, 2016 set the record with 7 faithless electors.

Has a faithless elector ever changed the outcome of an election?

No faithless elector has ever altered the winner of a presidential election. In every election where faithless votes occurred, the margin of victory was large enough that the rogue votes did not change the outcome.

LIVE · DE → EN
youtube.com/watch?v=BXIlqNP_ACo
Example video: Universität Wien Physik (CC BY) · not affiliated
Sponsored
Great lecture, in a language you don't speak?
Follow lectures and talks from any country

University lectures, conference talks, podcasts: live English subtitles while you watch, and a full transcript afterwards.

Detects the spoken language Searchable transcript afterwards No browser extension needed
Try live subtitles 7-day free trial · no card · macOS 14+